EFY Times  
Tuesday, May 22, 2012
 
GO
       Electronics       Infotech      Linux & Open Source       Consumer Electronics      Telecom      BPO      Science & Technology      tech4biz      Tablets      Aadhaar   
 
 
I Don't Use A Cellphone As It Can Track Me: Stallman
 
Home >> Infotech >> Interviews
 
I Don't Use A Cellphone As It Can Track Me: Stallman  
 
On a recent visit to India, Richard M Stallman spoke to EFYTimes about Android, Steve Jobs, Facebook, about not using a cellphone and the Indian Free Software community. Read on...    
Rate this news:  (9 Votes)
Thursday, February 23, 2012 When it comes to propagating Free Software, there can be no one as assertive as RMS (as Richard M Stallman is fondly known). Proprietary software, or anything that hampers freedom, is totally unacceptable to him. But before you meet him, make sure you are aware of all that he strongly believes in, or you could be caught on the wrong foot. Don’t utter the words Linux or Open Source in front of him---RMS doesn’t believe in them! He walks on the GNU/Linux and Free Software path.

On a recent visit to India, RMS talked to EFYTimes about Android, Steve Jobs, Facebook, his not using a cellphone and the Indian Free Software community.

You have expressed your rejection for Facebook. Why?

Facebook is not your friend, and is certainly not my friend. Facebook collects data on who was where, and when, and uses its so-called 'users' to collect its data. If you posted a photo of me in Facebook, people would be invited to label it as Richard Stallman—and their database will have more information about me. I don't want their database to have information about anybody.

Richard M Stallman, Richard Stallman, RMS, RMS visit to India, RMS Speaks on Facebook, Richard Stallman visit to India, RMS speaks on Android, Free laptops b y tamil Nadu government, ELCOT, Steve Jobs, RMS speaks on Steve jobs




Why have you asked your followers to not do business with Amazon through Stallman.org?

Amazon's Swindle is malware. That's not its official name, of course. I am talking of an e-book reader which is designed to swindle readers out of their traditional freedom of reading. There is a freedom to buy a book anonymously paying cash, which is the only way I buy books. I never give my name to be put in any database with the books I have bought; I don't want any database to have that information. With the Swindle, however, Amazon forces users to identify themselves to get identified with the books they have bought. Amazon has a giant database that records each book that each user has read—and such a database, no matter who has it, is a threat to human rights. We must not allow that to exist.

Then there is freedom to give a book to someone else, or to lend it to other people, or even to sell it, perhaps to a book store. Amazon eliminates this freedom with digital handcuffs, together with end-user license agreements.

And there is also freedom to keep a book for as long as you wish, and pass it on to your children. Amazon abolishes this freedom with a back-door. We know about these back-doors by observation. In 2009, users observed that Amazon remotely deleted thousands of copies of a particular book. These were authorised copies, until they were wiped off by Amazon. The book was 1984 by George Orwell, which is the most ironic choice possible. The official name of the product is Kindle, which means to start a fire. Evidently, this product was designed to burn our books—so don't let it happen! Don't ever use that product, or anything like it.

You said “I am glad Jobs' gone”. Can you elucidate why?

People distorted what I said. I said it's not good that he is dead, but it's good that he is gone. The reason I said it was because he was an evil genius, who did harm to the world. He figured out how to make computers that were like prison for the users, and he made them attractive, so that many users get attracted to the glamour, to be handcuffed. After he did this, Microsoft started doing the same thing. So he changed the world for the worse, and we are still fighting the harm that he did. That's the reason for what I said. Of the various things that Jobs did, this was the most dangerous. I am glad he is not able to do any more of this. I hope that his successors would be less successful than him.

Why don't you use a cellphone?

Because cellphones can track my location or my conversation with anyone. Most cellular phones, even if they are not smartphones, have a processor running software and that (proprietary) software is malware, because it will send information about its users' locations on remote command—and it has a back-door, so it can be remotely converted into a listening device. Almost all software has bugs—but this software in itself is a bug.

Based on your interactions with the community in India, what are your observations about the Free Software Movement in India?

Well, there are a few activists who have campaigned strongly for Free Software, and they have had some successes. Some of the schools in Kerala switched to free software—but most of the Free Software community is not thinking about freedom, and there are obstacles from the government. Schools are required to teach proprietary software (at least, some schools are, because they are under the control of the universities that require it, who in turn are controlled by the government bodies that require it). This is wrong. So any government that tells people to teach proprietary software is essentially delivering the country into the hands of a company. The Tamil Nadu government is distributing laptops with Windows to the children. Well, that's delivering the future of the state to a company. It's wrong. I have heard that they have now settled for a dual-boot system. Dual-boot means providing some ethical software and some unethical software. That's like saying at a lunch in school, “We will offer the children water and whisky, so they could get to know both of them.” Switching to dual-boot is a step forward, but they must stop distributing Windows. It's wrong to ever distribute non-free software to the public—and when it's given to children, it's even worse.

What are your views on the Indian developers’ contributions to Free Software?

Well, I don't follow that. You see, there are hundreds and thousands of free programs, and most of them I have never heard of. I don't try to keep a track of who is contributing what, because I cannot do that. I have other work to do. As a result, I am not in a position to measure the contributions of people from any particular country. However, I do know of one Indian developer who has made an important contribution. His name is Krishna Kant. He came to a talk I gave, and said that there was no Free Software that could speak words from the screen, and so asked what he ought to do? I said, “Write some.” So a few years later, he came to one of my talks, and reminded me of what I had said to him earlier—and said that he had ‘written some’. So now he has made major contributions to the screen-reading software, which he and thousands of other people use.

Diksha  P Gupta, EFYTIMES News Network


Print Email Post Comment  (4)
(Total Views: 23803)
 
Share
 
 

4 Comments

Nikhil   90 days ago

These are the type of people who make open source people look crazy.
Reply   1 Reply
Sebastien   88 days ago

He's smart and knows what he's talking about. That's the type of people that make me proud to support open source. Power to the people.
Reply   1 Reply
Patrick   86 days ago

He is specifically supporting free software not open source. The difference is that open source is a technical description free software a goal the results are close but the thinking is different. Moreover Open Source is not always incompatible with software patent free software is. With open source depending on the specific licence I can publish my code and still forbid you to use it or even reimplement something similar without my say so.Free software puts freedom before everything else. So yes I guess people who want to be free and help others to be free are crazy I'm proud to be one of them.
Reply   1 Reply
Nikhil   80 days ago

Good for you then. Lets help people by making them stop using cell phones gps and technology in general.All of us love the Open source community but I see myself as being one of the moderates. Closed source isn't bad either. Stallman is one of the hardliners and in my view these people are'nt too relevant today.
Reply  
 
Infotech News
   
"Thousands" Of Galaxy S III Pre-Ordered: Carphone Warehouse
Low-Cost Smartphones, Tablets Compromise On Security: Uninor
Spam Issue Is Not Location-Based: BitDefender
Bharatico BPO To Provide BPO Training Across India
Photo Tour: Mercury iXA Tab
 
 
 
     
     
     
Press Release
     
HiWave Strengthens Its Intellectual ...
Vodafone India FY12 Revenues Cross INR ...
Tata Comm Deploys Amdocs Solution To ...
Qualcomm Labs Teams With EvoNexus To ...
Tata Comm Full-Year Consolidated EBITDA ...
Delhi Duty Free Services Deploys ...
Bring Your Loved Ones Closer To You ...
Monster Application For iPhone Devices ...
Parallels Continues To Lead Hosting & ...
Beat The Heat This Summer With Latest ...
Micrium Brings Professional RTOS ...
Cortus Launches APS3R 32 bit ...
Stellar Phoenix Releases PDF Repair v1
Gartner Says Program & Portfolio ...
Kronos Survey Shows Employees Skip Work ...
Belkin Celebrates With 'Champions ...
Lumis Partners Provides A Fresh Order ...
EMC Launches 42 New Products Focused On ...
ASUS Launches First Intel Thunderbolt ...
Sony India Achieves Sales Of Rs. 6,313 ...
ZyXEL Ready With IPv6 Internet Products ...
Qualcomm Ventures Launches Third Annual ...
NEC To Scale Up Its Enterprise Sales ...
Pacnet, Infinera 1st To Demo 500 Gb/s ...
World’s 1st Airport To Trial SIM-based ...
 
Oracle Strengthens Its Product ...
Thane Janata Sahakari Bank Improves ...
Lenovo India Launches Trendy Desktops ...
LG Launches LW130W Cube Camera And ...
Watch India Internet Day 2012 Live ...
Quikr Attracts $32 Million Private ...
TI Intros Industry's First SAR ADC with ...
Airtel digital TV Launches iEnglish For ...
Microelectronic Design & Measurement ...
SMIC Employs Mentor Graphics Calibre ...
Linde Expands TFT-LCD Footprint in ...
GCT Delivers Chipset for Sierra 4G LTE ...
Cadence Powers Nufront Mobile App ...
Openet Leads Policy Market With VoLTE ...
Video And Audio Storage Requirements ...
First QFabric Top-of-Rack Switch Data ...
Kar Mobiles Limited Income Up 24% And ...
Huawei Leads 19 Million Indian Set-Top ...
APEM Celebrates Its 60th Anniversary
IBM Helps Axis Bank Transform Its ...
Anritsu Expands Calibration Facility In ...
Corelis Releases New CD Version 7.7 ...
Linear's 42V, 2.5A(IOUT), 2.2MHz ...
Indium Corporation Acquires New ...
PNY Introduces Whistle Attaché USB ...
     
     
     
     
     
Most popular
 
 
 
 
Features
Biometrics Market Has Immense Potential In India
With a significant increase in its application areas, the biometric devices market is poised to grow at a CAGR of 42.4 per cent by 2014. We explore if...
Importance Of Calibration For T&M Instruments
The impact of even a small error in measurement can be tremendous in terms of loss in revenue. Hence, even the smallest of errors in delivery (data ac...
 
  View All
Dialogue
 
Low-Cost Smartphones, Tablets Compromise On Security: Uninor
"There has to be some kind of standard, which needs to be established for these end-point devices that must be complied with by each manufacturer. The...
Indian Tablet Market Is A Key Segment For Us: Logitech
In conversation with EFYTimes, Subrotah Biswas, country manager, Logitech India and South West Asia spoke about the company's product line-up for tabl...
Digital Media Is Directly Measurable: Kenscio
Businesses have understood the consumer behaviour for a long time and are using those channels where consumers are spending time, whether at home, ...
Indian IT- ITes Sector Does Not Need Government Support: NIIT CEO
In an exclusive conversation with EFYTimes.com, Arvind Thakur, CEO, NIIT Technologies spoke about Indian IT and BPO industry and NIIT's perspective ab...
BPO Industry Should Move To Tier II Cities: Infosys
If a company could set up an outsourcing operation in a place like Assam or Guwahati, people would not want to move out. This will help in curbing ...
   
  View All
Daily App Review
 
Daily App Review: Waze-GPS & Traffic (iOS And Android)
Yes, we have maps and we have step-by-step navigation. But getting traffic details remains a pain in India. Unless you happen to be using Waze....
Daily App Review: Everything.me (Android And iOS)
It runs totally off the Web, needs no installation whatsoever, and does what is unthinkable to many people--gives Google and Bing a run for their mone...
Daily App Review: Discovr People (iOS)
So you have joined Twitter and have no idea about whom to follow. Don't worry, there's an app for that. ...
Daily App Review: Angry Birds Space (Android And iOS)
The flingable fowls are back. And this time, Rovio has finally added a new spin to the game, with some help from gravity. ...
Daily App Review: Nokia Drive 2.0 (Windows Phone)
One of the best navigation apps we have ever seen on a handset can now work in offline mode too. Yep, you can now get directions without a network con...
Daily App Review: Draw Something Free (Android And iOS)
Almost like clockwork, every few months there comes along an app that surprises everyone (including those who love it) by becoming a sensation. Angry ...
Daily App Review: Songify For iOS
Just speak normally. And this app will turn it into a song, complete with music. For free. ...
Daily App Review: Creative Studio (Lumia 800 And 710)
Windows Phone users--or at least those that have a Nokia Lumia 800 or Lumia 710--will be delighted at the news that Nokia has released a free image tw...
Daily App Review: Price of Persia Classic HD (iPad)
You can divide the world into two categories--those have played Prince of Persia and those who do not like playing videogames. And now the classic ver...
Daily App Review: Waze-GPS & Traffic (iOS And Android)
Yes, we have maps and we have step-by-step navigation. But getting traffic details remains a pain in India. Unless you happen to be using Waze....
Daily App Review: PressReader (iPad And Honeycomb)
It was one of the tech fantasies promised to us by sci-fi films--wake up in the morning and you will get the newspaper on a gadget that just needs to ...
Daily App Review: Pixlr-o-matic (Android)
You can say that there are two kinds of people who play around with photo apps on Android--those who keep asking for Instagram for Android and those w...
Daily App Review: Parking Frenzy 2.0 For Android
It is not often that you see Indian games shooting to the top of the popularity lists in the Android Market. Well, Parking Frenzy has managed to do ju...
Daily App Review: Klik For iPhone
Among all the gadgetry on display in Mission Impossible IV, perhaps the most striking was an iPhone app that could identify people who appeared on the...
Daily App Review: Dolphin Browser 7.4 HD (Android)
Dolphin HD, one of the most popular third-party browsers on Android, has just got an update. And with it comes voice recognition. ...
Daily App Review: Clear (iPhone And iPod touch)
Once in a while there comes along an app that some dismiss as being not useful enough, but which still gets downloaded by the thousands because the li...
   
 
Events
 
23 May: CPBCM Certification Workshop

25 May: Mumbai HR Summit 2012

25 May: COMSOL Multiphysics Seminar

27 May: Middle East Industrial Technology Leadership ...

4 Jun: BCS Foundation Certificate In Green IT

View All
   
   
 
 

home archives contact us advertise with us
           
Magazines Portals Directories Events News Verticals Educational Institute  
Electronics for You
LINUX for You
Facts for You
Electronics Bazaar
electronicsforu.com
efytimes.com
bpotimes.com
linuxforu.com
Electronics Annual Guide
EFY EXPO
EFY Awards
EduTech Expo
OSIWEEK Expo
Electronics
Infotech
Linux & Open Source
Consumer Electronics
Science & Technology
BPO
EFY Techcenter 
 
 
© Copyright 2012 EFY Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.
All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without written permission is prohibited.
Usage of the content from the web site is subject to Terms and Conditions